Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Landy R. Rajaovelona ( l.rajaovelona@kew.org ) Academic editor: Brecht Verstraete
© 2026 Landy R. Rajaovelona, Jakub D. Wieczorkowski, Velosoa Razafiniary, Ary Misa Andry Ny Aina, Miadana A. Faramalala, Besoa M. R. Ramaminirina, Caroline E. R. Lehmann, Ai-Qun Hu, Oscar A. Pérez-Escobar, Isabel Larridon, Mijoro Rakotoarinivo.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Rajaovelona L, Wieczorkowski JD, Razafiniary V, Andry Ny Aina AM, Faramalala MA, Ranjavao BMR, Lehmann CER, Hu A-Q, Pérez-Escobar OA, Larridon I, Rakotoarinivo M (2026) Assessing the extinction risk of Malagasy orchids to develop effective conservation approaches – a case study of the Itremo Massif Protected Area. Plant Ecology and Evolution 159(2): 310-324. https://doi.org/10.5091/plecevo.185223
|
Background and aims – Madagascar harbours high numbers of threatened orchid species, making it critical for orchid conservation. The Itremo Massif Protected Area (Itremo Massif PA), a Key Biodiversity Area in the Central Highlands, comprises diverse habitats essential for orchid survival. Previously, only 30% of the 83 orchid species recorded in the Itremo Massif PA had been assessed for the IUCN Red List. This research documents and analyses their habitats and threats to propose conservation approaches.
Material and methods – We compiled a dataset of orchid species native to the Itremo Massif PA, including information on endemicity, conservation status, habitats, and threats from IUCN Red List assessments and field observations. A species-by-habitat matrix was constructed, and species composition across habitats was analysed using a β-diversity framework. Overall β-diversity (βSOR) was partitioned into species turnover and nestedness components. We also evaluated the proportion of threatened orchid species (Critically Endangered – CR, Endangered – EN and Vulnerable – VU) associated with the primary habitats and threats in the PA.
Key results – Of the 83 orchid species native to the Itremo Massif PA, 64% (53 spp.) are endemic to Madagascar and 41% (34 spp.) are threatened (1 CR, 16 EN, 17 VU). Species composition varies markedly between habitats (βSOR = 0.83), primarily driven by species turnover (0.66). Bare soil and rock host the most orchid species (60%, 50 spp.). Bare soil and rock and grassland share the most species (14%, 12 spp.), while humid forest contains the most species restricted to a single habitat (16%, 13 spp.). Orchids are primarily threatened by mining and quarrying, increased fire intensity/frequency, logging and wood harvesting, and shifting agriculture.
Conclusion – Conservation should prioritise humid forest for its unique orchid species, and bare soil and rock for their richness in endemic and threatened species. Grassland also represents essential habitat for terrestrial orchids. Further research on population dynamics, pollination, and fungal interactions is needed to better assess extinction risk and manage conservation.
conservation, fire, habitat preference, Important Plant Area, IUCN Red List, mining, Orchidaceae
Orchidaceae is one of the most species-rich families of flowering plants with around 31,000 species (
Madagascar is among the world’s important centres of orchid diversity and endemism. The island hosts a high number of threatened orchid species (
The Itremo Massif Protected Area (Itremo Massif PA), situated in Madagascar’s Central Highlands, represents an important focus for plant conservation due to its notable botanical richness including 749 plant species, 353 genera, and 103 families (
Location of the Itremo Massif Protected Area, in Amoron’i Mania region, South-Central Madagascar. The habit types by
Of the 83 orchid species recorded in the Itremo Massif PA, only 34 species have been assessed on the IUCN Red List (
Orchid conservation in Madagascar’s Central Highlands faces multiple interacting challenges. High endemism and narrow habitat ranges make orchids sensitive to environmental changes (
These combined pressures highlight the urgent need for targeted conservation. This study aims to assess the conservation status and set conservation priorities for orchids in the Itremo Massif PA by answering the following questions: (1) How many orchid species native to the Itremo Massif PA are currently classified under IUCN threatened categories? (2) What are the primary habitats of Itremo orchids and how does species composition vary across habitats? and (3) What are the main threats to orchids in the Itremo Massif PA? Finally, we propose actions to preserve orchid biodiversity in the area.
Data on endemicity, IUCN conservation status, habitats, and threats were extracted and compiled from two main sources: (1) field observations and online databases, including data from
Species were marked as endemic to Madagascar if they only occur in Madagascar based on the distribution data recorded in
We conducted full IUCN Red List assessments following the guidelines set out in the IUCN Red List Categories and Criteria (
The habitats of orchid species occurring in the Itremo Massif PA were defined by integrating the vegetation classification of
Bare soil and rock include granitic inselbergs and landscapes dominated by exposed rock in the Central Highlands. Cultivation includes croplands, rice fields, and areas used for agroforestry. Wetland comprises marshes, swamps and peatlands. In the Itremo Massif PA, humid forest corresponds to gallery forests maintained by water sources. Although the western dry forest is not present within the Itremo Massif PA, it was included in the analysis because some species with broad ecological niches that occur in western dry forest elsewhere in Madagascar are native to the Itremo Massif PA where they are found in other habitats such as humid forest. Including the western dry forest habitat category in the analysis is therefore necessary to represent the full ecological distribution of these species in Madagascar more widely.
The threats facing orchid species at global level were classified following the Guidance on Threats and Stresses Classification Scheme Version 3.3 (
The flowering period of each orchid species was compiled from field observations and from the plant species checklist of the Itremo Massif PA (
Analyses were conducted in R v.4.3.1 (
The endemicity in Madagascar and IUCN conservation status for each orchid species occurring in the Itremo Massif PA are provided in Suppl. material
Summary of endemicity and extinction risk of orchids native to the Itremo Massif Protected Area. Species indicated with an asterisk (*) are endemic or near-endemic to the Itremo Massif Protected Area.
| Endemicity and extinction risk | Number of species | Species list |
| Endemic to Madagascar and threatened | 30 | Aerangis ellisii, Aerangis fuscata, Aerangis pallidiflora, Aeranthes ramosa, *Angraecum coutrixii, *Angraecum magdalenae, Angraecum popowii, Angraecum protensum, *Benthamia praecox, Benthamia rostrata, Brachycorythis disoides, Bulbophyllum callosum, *Bulbophyllum humbertii, Cynorkis cardiophylla, Cynorkis cinnabarina, *Cynorkis melinantha, *Cynorkis sacculata, Eulophia ibityensis, Eulophia macra, Habenaria alta, Habenaria ambositrana, Habenaria bathiei, *Habenaria monadenioides, *Habenaria quartzicola, *Jumellea ibityana, Jumellea intricata, *Jumellea spathulata, Polystachya henrici, Polystachya monophylla, Tylostigma tenellum |
| Endemic to Madagascar and non-threatened | 23 | Angraecum arachnites, Angraecum compactum, Angraecum rutenbergianum, Angraecum sororium, Benthamia flavida, Benthamia glaberrima, Bulbophyllum baronii, Bulbophyllum bicoloratum, Cynorkis baronii, Cynorkis gibbosa, Cynorkis gigas, Cynorkis lilacina, Cynorkis papillosa, Cynorkis purpurea, Cynorkis uniflora, Disa incarnata, Eulophia ramosa, Eulophia reticulata, Eulophia rutenbergiana, Calanthe francoisii, Habenaria simplex, Jumellea densefoliata, Satyrium rostratum |
| Non-endemic to Madagascar and threatened | 4 | Aeranthes strangulata, Benthamia bathieana, Eulophia pileata, Tylostigma hildebrandtii |
| Non-endemic to Madagascar and non-threatened | 26 | Aerangis punctata, Angraecopsis parviflora, Angraecum calceolus, Angraecum leonis, Angraecum mauritianum, Angraecum pectinatum, Bulbophyllum occlusum, Calanthe sylvatica, Cynorkis fastigiata, Cynorkis flexuosa, Cynorkis graminea, Cynorkis lindleyana, Eulophia hians, Eulophia livingstoneana, Eulophia plantaginea, Habenaria incarnata, Jumellea stenophylla, Neobathiea grandidieriana, Nervilia simplex, Polystachya anceps, Polystachya concreta, Polystachya cultriformis, Polystachya fusiformis, Polystachya rosea, Satyrium amoenum, Satyrium trinerve |
Bare soil and rock, humid forest, and grassland are the three most orchid-rich habitats in the Itremo Massif PA (Fig.
A total of 28.9% (24 species) is restricted to a single habitat: 15.6% (13 spp.) are exclusive to humid forest, 10.8% (9 spp.) restricted to bare soil and rock, and 2.4% (2 spp.) to grassland. Bare soil and rock and grassland share the highest number of species 14.5% (12 spp.), followed by humid forest and bare soil and rock 9.6% (8 spp.), and grassland and wetland 6.2% (5 spp.). Seventy-one percent (59 spp.) occur in three or four habitats within the Itremo Massif PA (Suppl. material
Species composition across vegetation types in the Itremo Massif Protected Area. UpSet plot showing the number of orchid species shared among different habitat combinations (2, 3, or 4 habitats) and species unique to each habitat. Each bar represents the number of species in each habitat combination, indicated by the connected dots below the bars. Individual dots represent species unique to a single habitat, while connected dots represent shared species between two to four habitats. The set size (0–50) is the total number of species recorded in each habitat, some habitats may have 50 species, others poor species (close to 0). The total number of species in each habitat includes species unique to that habitat and those shared with other habitats.
The overall β-diversity across all habitats was high (βSOR = 0.83) indicating that each habitat is composed mainly of distinct orchid species. The turnover component or species replacement was high (βSIM = 0.66), and the nestedness component or species loss was low (βSNE = 0.17). These results indicated that difference in orchid composition is primarily due to species replacement between habitats. Pairwise β-diversity analysis (Table
Summary of (β-diversity) analysis based on orchid species composition in different habitats in the Itremo Massif PA: βSOR (overall β-diversity, measured as Sørensen dissimilarity), βSIM (turnover component, measured as Sørensen metrix), βSNE (nestedness component, measured as a Simpson metric). Cultivation was excluded from the analysis as it was represented by only one species.
| Habitat1 & Habitat2 | βSOR | βSIM | βSNE | Shared species | Unique species Habitat1 | Unique species Habitat2 |
| Humid forest & Bare soil and rock | 0.64 | 0.6 | 0.04 | 8 | 13 | 9 |
| Humid forest & Tapia woodland | 0.67 | 0.52 | 0.15 | 4 | 13 | 0 |
| Humid forest & Grassland | 0.84 | 0.82 | 0.01 | 1 | 13 | 2 |
| Humid forest & Wetland | 0.96 | 0.93 | 0.03 | 0 | 13 | 0 |
| Humid forest & Western dry forest | 0.86 | 0.25 | 0.61 | 3 | 13 | 0 |
| Bare soil and rock & Tapia woodland | 0.63 | 0.38 | 0.25 | 3 | 9 | 0 |
| Bare soil and rock & Grassland | 0.48 | 0.35 | 0.12 | 12 | 9 | 2 |
| Bare soil and rock & Wetland | 0.78 | 0.53 | 0.25 | 2 | 9 | 0 |
| Bare soil and rock & Western dry forest | 0.96 | 0.75 | 0.21 | 0 | 9 | 0 |
| Tapia woodland & Grassland | 0.71 | 0.62 | 0.09 | 2 | 2 | 2 |
| Tapia woodland & Wetland | 0.83 | 0.8 | 0.03 | 0 | 2 | 0 |
| Tapia woodland & Western dry forest | 0.92 | 0.75 | 0.17 | 0 | 2 | 0 |
| Grassland & Wetland | 0.55 | 0.27 | 0.28 | 5 | 2 | 0 |
| Grassland & Western dry forest | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 |
| Wetland & Western dry forest | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Seven of the 12 threats based to the IUCN Classification Scheme affect orchid species native to the Itremo Massif PA. Four threats, i.e. mining and quarrying, increase in fire intensity/frequency, shifting agriculture, and logging and wood harvesting are the most significant threats to orchid species (Fig.
Mining and quarrying represent the major threat to orchids in the Itremo Massif PA by affecting 21 (60%) of the 34 threatened species recorded (1 CR, 7 EN, and 13 VU). Lithophytic orchids such as Cynorkis sacculata (CR), Angraecum coutrixii (EN), C. melinantha (EN), Jumellea ibityana (EN), and J. spathulata (EN) grow in small and fragmented orchid population, on bare soil and rock, affected by mining within the Itremo Massif PA (Landy R. Rajaovelona pers. obs. 2022).
The increase in fire frequency/intensity is the second threat by affecting 12 (34%) threatened species (6 EN, 6 VU). Angraecum protensum Schltr., Jumellea ibityana, and J. spathulata, are examples of orchids in the area that have aerial roots. As a result, these species may be sensitive to heat damage. In addition, Polystachya monophylla Schltr., Eulophia ibityensis Schltr., and E. macra Ridl. are examples of threatened orchid species at risk because fire can destroy the above ground pseudobulbs. Both shifting agriculture and logging and wood harvesting are a third threat by impacting each 9 (7%) threatened orchids (3 EN, 6 VU and 2 EN, 7 VU) (Suppl. material
Based on field observations, seasonal fires occur between July and October in the Itremo Massif PA. Based on the data presented in Suppl. material
Our research shows that the Itremo Massif Protected Area supports a rich orchid flora, with 53 species endemic to Madagascar—representing 64% of the 83 species recorded in the area. Of these, 34 species (41%) are classified as threatened according to IUCN Red List assessments. Although substantial, the proportions of endemic and threatened species in the Itremo Massif PA are lower than national estimates (83% and 76%, respectively;
Mining and quarrying, including extraction of stones like crystal and tourmaline, are the main threat to 21 threatened orchids in the Itremo Massif PA which aligns with findings by
Increase in fire frequency/intensity is the second most significant threat to orchids in the Itremo Massif PA, affecting 12 threatened species. Lithophytes, growing on exposed rocks, are vulnerable to fire as they lack underground tubers for resprouting after burning (
The role of fire is also linked to the spread of invasive Pinus L. species, which have been increasingly recorded in tapia woodland in Madagascar’s Central Highlands (
Shifting agriculture, and logging/wood harvesting represent the third major threat in the Itremo Massif PA, each affecting nine threatened orchid species. These threats mostly impact epiphytic species in the genera Aerangis Rchb.f., Aeranthes Lindl., and Bulbophyllum Thouars, which are restricted to humid forest and tapia woodland in the Itremo Massif PA. Shifting agriculture and logging/wood harvesting reduces canopy cover, increases exposure to heat and drought, and disrupts the fine-scale microhabitats for epiphytes (
Protecting orchid diversity in the Itremo Massif PA requires habitat conservation strategies that address the ecological requirements of species and the varied threats across habitats. We suggest the following actions to preserve the orchid diversity in the Itremo Massif PA.
Further fieldwork is strongly recommended to better document rare orchids (Fig.
Examples of orchids occurring in the Itremo Massif Protected Area. A. Cynorkis cinnabarina (VU). B. C. melinantha (EN). C. Neobathiea grandidieriana (LC). D. Angraecum rutenbergianum (LC). E. A. coutrixii (CR). F. Jumellea spathulata (EN). G. Cynorkis cardiophylla (VU). H. Benthamia bathieana (VU). Photos by Narindra Romer Rabarijaona (A, C) and Landy R. Rajaovelona (B, D–H).
The highest concentration of threatened orchids is found in the bare soil and rock, humid forest, and grassland habitats and these are therefore the highest priority for conservation.
Installing firebreaks around sensitive habitats, fire patrolling, and planning early season burns (May–July) to prevent high-intensity fires.
Designate orchid-rich outcrops, humid forest, and tapia woodland as strict no mining zones because mining practices are a major driver of biodiversity loss (
The removal of invasive Pinus species combined with appropriate fire management is necessary to maintain the open structure of tapia woodland, which is essential for conserving orchid diversity. Epiphytic orchids depend on microhabitats shaped by canopy openness and light conditions, making them sensitive to changes in forest structure (
Ex situ conservation is feasible for orchids when local communities are actively engaged in the maintenance of shade houses and/or nurseries, combined with understanding of orchid ecological requirements. This is particularly important for terrestrial and lithophytic orchids which have complex growth cycles, including seasonal dormancy, tuber formation, making their long- term cultivation challenging due to specific substrate, light and moisture requirements. Local shade houses and nurseries play a role in maintaining living collections, producing material for restoration or reintroduction, and supporting seed banking (
To achieve successful conservation outcomes, it is important to promote stakeholder-inclusive and participatory conservation (
Already recognised as a Key Biodiversity Area (KBA), we suggest its designation as Important Plant Area (IPA) to strengthen site-specific plant management (
Orchidaceae are the second most species-rich family after Poaceae in the Itremo Massif PA. This study provides the first assessment of orchid extinction risk within the PA, located in the Madagascar Central Highlands, characterised by various habitats such as grassland, bare soil and rock, humid forest, and tapia woodland. Understanding habitat diversity, species composition, extinction risk and associate threats are essential for informing effective management strategies of this plant group. The Itremo Massif PA harbours threatened orchid species, which have restricted distributions and small population sizes. These species require urgent conservation actions, including habitat protection and both in situ and ex situ measures. Humid forest is particularly important as it hosts orchid species not found in other habitats. Grassland also represents essential habitat for terrestrial orchids in the Itremo Massif PA. Orchids of bare soil and rock are vulnerable to mining activities and increase in fire intensity/frequency. Long-term conservation actions include controlling pine invasion in the tapia woodland combined with implementing fire management.
Orchidaceae are among the most threatened plant families in part due to their complex life histories and highly specific interactions with pollinators and mycorrhizal fungi (
The authors express their gratitude to all who help on providing data and facilities for conducting this research: Jack Plummer and Amy Baker, in the Plant Assessment Unit of the Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew and Dr Solohery Rapanarivo and Dr Franck Rakotonasolo from the Parc Botanique et Zoologique de Tsimbazaza, Antananarivo. We also thank the Direction des Aires Protégées, des Ressources Naturelles Renouvelables et des Ecosystèmes (DAPRNE) at the Ministère de l’Environnement et du Développement Durable for delivering research and export permits. We are grateful to the local guides in the Itremo Massif PA who have supported our field work. Our warmest thank to the colleagues from Kew Madagascar for all their help. This research was funded by the Today’s Flora for Tomorrow project funded by a generous donor through Kew Development, allowing the first author to pursue a PhD at the University of Antananarivo in collaboration with Royal Botanic Gardens, Kew.
Endemicity in Madagascar and extinction risk of orchid species in the Itremo Massif PA. Proportion of endemic and non-endemic orchids across IUCN categories: Critically Endangered (CR), Endangered (EN), Vulnerable (VU), Near Threatened (NT), and Least Concern (LC).
Rationales for the submitted IUCN Red List assessments.
Number and list of shared orchid species for each habitat combination (paired, three or four habitats) for Itremo Massif PA orchids.
Dataset of species, IUCN status, habitat, and threat to orchids in the Itremo Massif PA.
Habitat species binary: Presence (1) or absence (0) of each orchid species in each of the seven habitats (bare soil and rock, cultivation, humid forest, tapia woodland, grassland, western dry forest, and wetland) in the Itremo Massif PA.
Number and list of orchid species (CR, EN, VU, NT, LC) by the seven habitats for orchids found in the Itremo Massif PA.
Number and list of orchid species (CR, EN, VU, NT, LC) by the seven major threats found in the Itremo Massif PA.
Fire season and flowering time dataset of the Itremo Massif PA orchids.