Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Petra De Block ( petra.deblock@plantentuinmeise.be ) Academic editor: Isabel Larridon
© 2026 Petra De Block, Franck Rakotonasolo, Arne Mertens, Sylvain G. Razafimandimbison, Brecht Verstraete.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
De Block P, Rakotonasolo F, Mertens A, Razafimandimbison SG, Verstraete B (2026) Two new dioecious species of Vanguerieae (Rubiaceae) from limestone regions in Madagascar. Plant Ecology and Evolution 159(2): 255-267. https://doi.org/10.5091/plecevo.177167
|
Background and aims – The Paleotropical tribe Vanguerieae (Rubiaceae) is centred in Africa and Madagascar. In Madagascar, many of its ca 150 species are functionally dioecious, belonging to the small genus Bullockia and two large genera, Pyrostria (~90 species) and Peponidium (~50 species). These species estimates include many undescribed species, two of which are formally described here.
Material and methods – A Bayesian inference of ITS sequence data from Vanguerieae was performed to pinpoint the generic placement of the new taxa. Morphological studies were conducted based on standard methods of herbarium taxonomy. The new species are described in detail, illustrated, and compared to morphological similar species. Distribution maps are presented and the preliminary conservation status of the new taxa was evaluated using IUCN criteria.
Key results – Two new species of Malagasy Vanguerieae are described. ITS data place one in the genus Peponidium and one in the genus Pyrostria. Peponidium calciphilum sp. nov. is endemic to the Tsingy of Ankarana in northern Madagascar, while Pyrostria multilocellata sp. nov. is restricted to the spiny thickets in dry southern and southwestern Madagascar. Both species occur on limestone and in dry vegetation types, have 4-merous, functionally dioecious flowers, and bilocular fruits. Peponidium calciphilum sp. nov. is characterized by ovate, sessile leaves with cordate bases, well-developed subulate stipules, glabrous shoots, ovaries, and calyces, distinct tufts of hairs at the tips of the calyx lobes, and vaulted corolla lobes with well-developed appendages. Pyrostria multilocellata sp. nov. is characterized by very small, strongly coriaceous to almost succulent leaves, single-flowered male and female inflorescences, minute flowers, and multilocellate anthers in the male flowers. Peponidium calciphilum sp. nov. is considered as Endangered, whereas Pyrostria multilocellata sp. nov. is estimated to be Near Threatened.
Ankarana, functional dioecy, ITS, multilocellate anthers, new species, Peponidium, Pyrostria, Toliara
The tribe Vanguerieae (Rubiaceae) is Paleotropical, with ca 650 species in 29 genera (
In Madagascar, most Vanguerieae species have functionally dioecious flowers. The large variation in flower and fruit morphology of the Malagasy dioecious Vanguerieae led to the historical description of species in several genera, notably Pyrostria Comm. ex A.Juss., Peponidium (Baill.) Arènes, Canthium Lam., and the endemic genera Leroya Cavaco, Neoleroya Cavaco, and Pseudopeponidium Homolle ex Arènes. Subsequent morphological (e.g.
In this study, we investigated two new Malagasy Vanguerieae species, collected during recent field work. Although their delimitation as distinct species was clear, it was difficult to assign them to genera. We therefore tested their generic placement by adding new ITS sequence data to an existing sequence alignment of Vanguerieae (
Descriptions are based on dried and alcohol-preserved samples housed in the herbaria BR and P (acronyms according to
For scanning electron microscopy (SEM), material was washed twice in 70% ethanol for 5 minutes, transferred to a 1:1 mixture of dimethoxymethane and 70% ethanol for 5 minutes and, then placed in 100% dimethoxymethane for 20 minutes. The material was subsequently critical point dried with liquid CO2 using a Balzers CPD 030 critical point dryer (BAL-TEC, Balzers, Liechtenstein). The dried samples were mounted on aluminium stubs with Leit-C carbon adhesive tape and coated with a platinum palladium mixture using a Cressington JFC-2300/208HR sputter coater. SEM images were obtained with a JEOL JSM7100F field emission scanning electron microscope (JEOL Ltd., Tokyo, Japan).
Genomic DNA was extracted from silica-dried leaf samples of the new species using an adapted CTAB protocol (
All sequences were automatically aligned with MAFFT v.7.490 (
The two new species are functionally dioecious, placing them within the dioecious Vanguerieae lineage. Generic delimitation within the dioecious Malagasy Vanguerieae has long been problematic. Important characters once used to delimit genera included the number of locules, the shape and size of the fruit, and the shape, size and deciduousness of the bracts supporting the inflorescence. However, subsequent analyses have shown that the number of locules is homoplasious within the dioecious Malagasy Vanguerieae, having evolved independently multiple times, and fruit size and shape show a continuous variation (
In the ITS analysis (Fig.
Bayesian inference phylogram of tribe Vanguerieae based on ITS sequence data. Bayesian posterior probabilities are indicated at the nodes. Representatives of Peponidium are indicated in green, those of Pyrostria in blue. Accessions of the two new species are given in bold and indicated with an arrowhead.
MADAGASCAR – Antsiranana province, Diana region, Ambilobe District • Ankarana, road from campement des Anglais towards campement des Américains (not beyond first savanna); 82 m; 13 Jan. 2002; fl. (functionally male); De Block, Rakotonasolo & Randriamboavonjy 1182; holotype: BR [BR0000020242732]; isotypes: BR [BR0000020242749, BR0000009757653, BR0000009757554], G*, K*, MO*, P*, S*, TAN.
Peponidium calciphilum De Block (functionally male specimen). A. Habit. B. Flowering node, showing stipule and axillary inflorescences. C. Inflorescence, side view. D. Pedicel, ovary, and calyx. E. Corolla, anthers, style, and stigma. F. Style and stigma. G. Stamen, adaxial view. H. Fruit. A–G from De Block et al. 1182 (BR); H from De Block et al. 997 (BR). Drawn by Hilde Orye.
Peponidium calciphilum resembles P. sessile Klack. & Razafim. by the sessile, ovate leaves with cordate bases, the glabrous calyx with distinct tufts of hairs at the tips of the lobes, the vaulted corolla lobes with well-developed appendages at the tips, and the preference for growing on limestone, but differs from it by the glabrous young shoots (vs covered with ± orange-brown erect hairs), the larger size of the leaves (6–9.5 × 2.5–5 cm vs 3–5.5 × 1.5–3.5 cm) and stipules (6–9 vs 1.5–2.5 mm long), the higher number of flowers in the female inflorescences (3–8 vs 1–2), the larger flowers (functionally male flowers with corolla tube ca 2.5 mm long and lobes 3.2–3.5 mm long vs tube ca 0.7 mm long and lobes ca 1.6 mm long), and the shorter pedicels in fruiting stage (2–6 mm vs up to 16 mm long).
Shrub 1–2 m tall; young internodes laterally flattened, glabrous, brown, smooth, first becoming orange to reddish brown and glossy, later pale cream or grey, flaking; branches terete, glabrous, with greyish brown bark, somewhat corky. Leaves opposite, sessile; blades ovate, 6.0–9.5 × 2.5–5.0 cm, subcoriaceous to thinly coriaceous, glabrous and glossy on both surfaces, drying brown to dark brown and not discolorous; base cordate; apex subacute to shortly acuminate, with acumen ≤ 1 cm long, its tip obtuse to rounded; margin flat to somewhat revolute; midrib raised on both surfaces when dry, 6–7 secondary nerves on each side of midrib, hardly raised on either surface; small hairy pit domatia sometimes present in axils of basal secondary nerves. Stipules caducous, 6–9 mm long, subulate, consisting of a triangular basal sheath 2.5–3.5 mm long and a robust awn 3.0–5.5 mm long, glabrous externally except for some patches of short, appressed, orange-brown hairs at the base of the sheath on both sides and sometimes with a few hairs at the tip. Species functionally dioecious; female inflorescences (only seen in fruiting stage) delicate, sessile, with 1–3 flowers, subtended by a cup-like structure consisting of fused bracts; male inflorescences pluriflorous, with short, robust, 1–2 mm long peduncle, one part of the inflorescence consisting of flower remnants such as remains of pedicels and bracteoles (Fig.
Dry semi-deciduous or deciduous forest, on limestone covered by red sand; elevation 50–200 m.
Flowers in December–January and fruits in February–May.
The specific epithet means “limestone loving” and is chosen because the species only grows in the Tsingy of Ankarana on limestone.
Peponidium calciphilum is only known from the Ankarana Special Reserve. Detailed coordinates are not available for all specimens, so we choose the surface of the reserve as the maximum AOO, notably ca 240 km2. With five known specimens, the AOO is at most 20 km2. Both AOO and EOO comply with the Endangered category under, respectively, criterion B1 and B2. The species is collected from less than five locations in the Ankarana Special Reserve, which again complies with the Endangered category under subcriterion ‘a’ of criterion B2. The Ankarana Special Reserve is protected legally, which would suggest the absence of any threat. In reality, however, infringements into the Ankarana Special Reserve are common: bushfires, clearing for slash-and-burn agriculture, illegal logging for hardwood, firewood, and the production of charcoal, hunting, collection of plant species for medicinal or subsistence use, and illegal mining for sapphires all occur within its boundaries (
MADAGASCAR – Antsiranana Province, Diana region, Ambilobe District • Réserve Spéciale d’Ankarana, piste vers le lac Vert, à partir de la plaque de Tsingy; 180 m; 19 Feb. 1994; fr.; Andrianarisata, Lewis, McDonagh, Andriatsiferana, Randriambololona & Andrianantoanina 33; MO n.v., P [P00274292] • Matsaborimanga, Réserve d’Ankarana, piste Grim à proximité du camp des Anglais; 9 Dec. 1997; fl. (functionally male); Bardot-Vaucoulon & Toly 1036; K*, MO*, P (unmounted) • Ankarana, close to campement des Anglais, 82 m; 25 May 1999; fr.; De Block, Rapanarivo & Randriamboavonjy 997; BR [BR0000009758025, BR0000009757929], G*, MO*, P*, TAN • Ankarana, road from campement des Anglais towards campement des Américains (not beyond first savanna); 82 m; 13 Jan. 2002; fl. (functionally male); De Block, Rakotonasolo & Randriamboavonjy 1182; BR [BR0000020242732, BR0000020242749, BR0000009757653, BR0000009757554], G*, K*, MO*, P*, S*, TAN • Réserve Spéciale d’Ankarana, sur le Tsingy, piste vers le village Matsaborimanga; 180 m; 19 Feb. 1994; fr.; Rahajasoa, Lewis, McDonagh, Andrianantoanina, Ravelonarivo & Rasoavimbahoaka 176; MO n.v., P [P00274293].
In living plants with functionally male inflorescences, the leaves are dark green above. The bracts, bracteoles, pedicels, ovaries and calyces are pale green. The corolla tubes and lobes are greenish white outside and the lobes white inside. The anthers and filaments, style and stigma are white. Ripe fruits are dark to reddish pink in colour.
Peponidium calciphilum and P. sessile (
Three hair types occur in the reproductive structures of this species. The hairs on the tip of the calyx lobes, the tip of the corolla lobes, and the cilia on the bracts are orange-brown, unicellular, relatively short, and stiff. The hairs forming the dense ring in the throat are also unicellular, but much longer than the first type, translucent, and soft. This is in contrast to P. sessile for which the hairs at the throat are described as moniliform (
MADAGASCAR – Toliara Province, Atsimo-Andrefana Region, Toliara II District • La Table, 15 km from Toliara on Route Nationale 7; 4 Jan. 1999; fl. (functionally male); De Block, Leyman, Dessein, Rakotonasolo & Randriamboavonjy 544; holotype: BR [BR0000009125025]; isotypes: MO*, P*, S*, TAN.
Pyrostria multilocellata De Block. A. Habit. B. Brachyblast, showing stipules and terminal leaf pairs. C. Brachyblast, detail. D. Leaf, showing lower surface with domatia. E. Domatium. F, H, J, L, M. Functionally female flower. G, I, K. Functionally male flower. G, H. Pedicel, bracteolar cone, ovary, and calyx. I, J. Corolla, anthers, style, and stigma. K. Stamen, adaxial view, showing multilocellate anther. L. Style and stigma. M. Longitudinally opened corolla. N. Fruit. A–E, G, I, K from De Block et al. 2307 (BR), F, H, J, L, M from Groeninckx et al. 323 (BR); N from Groeninckx et al. 325 (BR). Drawn by Hilde Orye.
SEM micrographs of flowers of Pyrostria multilocellata. A, C, D. Functionally female flower. B, E, F. Functionally male flower. A, B. Fused bracteoles, ovary, and calyx. C. Inner surface of corolla lobe. D. Stigma. E. Corolla tube and lobe, stamen and ring of deflexed hairs at the level of insertion of the stamens. F. Detail of anther. A, D from Groeninckx et al. 323 (BR); B, C, E, F from De Block et al. 2307 (BR). Scale bars: 100 µm
The species resembles Pyrostria serpentina Lantz, Klack. & Razafim. by the habit (densely branched shrub), the very small coriaceous to somewhat succulent leaves, the extremely pauciflorous inflorescences (both male and female), and the small flowers and fruits, but differs from it by the following characters: branches erect (vs tortuously twisting), ovary (if developed) densely pubescent (vs glabrous), calyx lobes triangular with acute tips and bases not overlapping (vs calyx lobes low and rounded, overlapping at the base), or, calyx with an uneven, ± truncate, ciliate margin (vs margin glabrous), and the multilocellate anthers in the functionally male flowers (vs anthers non-multilocellate).
Subshrub or shrub, 0.5–2(–3) m tall, creeping to erect, hard-wooded, densely branched, each branch with many brachyblasts up to 2–3 cm long; young internodes laterally flattened, pale straw-coloured and densely covered with short erect to spreading hairs, rapidly flaking and then glabrous; branches terete, older branches with greyish bark, younger branches with smooth, dark reddish brown or blackish bark. Leaves opposite, usually grouped terminally on brachyblasts, the lower parts of the brachyblasts with leaves fallen and only stipules remaining (stipules densely positioned without any stem surface visible), more rarely on longer shoots with extended internodes; blades elliptic to obovate, 3–8 × 1.5–3.5(–4.0) mm, thickly coriaceous to succulent, glabrous on both surfaces or sparsely to densely covered with short erect to appressed hairs on the upper surface and with somewhat longer appressed hairs on the lower surface, drying brown and dull above, somewhat paler below; base cuneate to acute; apex mucronulate, blunt with a short point or rounded; margin flat to somewhat revolute, sometimes sparsely ciliate; only midrib visible, faintly impressed on upper surface, faintly raised on lower surface; rarely (1–)2–4 hairy pit domatia present on lower leaf surface, either opposite or alternately positioned. Petioles articulate, 0.5–1.0 mm long, canaliculate above, glabrous or sparsely to densely covered with erect or appressed hairs. Stipules triangular, ca 1 mm long, keeled, tip acute to obtuse, glabrous or sparsely to densely covered with erect or appressed hairs outside. Species functionally dioecious; female and male inflorescences uniflorous, sessile; pedicels 0–1 mm long in both flowering and fruiting stage, glabrous or pubescent; bracteoles fused into a cup-like structure 0.5–0.6 mm long, glabrous outside, glabrous but with a dense ring of large colleters at the base inside, margins ciliate with ± long hairs. Flowers 4-merous, functionally dioecious; corolla aestivation valvate and somewhat induplicate; calyx tube 0.3–0.5 mm long, glabrous outside, glabrous and without colleters inside, unevenly truncate with ciliate margin or calyx lobes triangular, 0.2–0.4 mm long, glabrous outside, glabrous or with appressed hairs inside, margins ciliate, bases not overlapping, tips acute; corolla tube glabrous outside, with a ring of long deflexed white hairs at the level of insertion of the anthers but otherwise glabrous inside, hairs not visible from outside; corolla lobes rounded triangular, glabrous inside and outside but margins thickened and papillate, tip acute to shortly acuminate and hood-like, with one or a few short hairs at the tip; stamens inserted at the throat, anthers erect, partly exserted from the corolla tube at anthesis, medifixed, filaments 0.2–0.3 mm long, base sagittate, tip rounded, papillate; style glabrous, stigma completely exserted from the corolla tube at anthesis, 0.3–0.5 × 0.3–0.65 mm long; ovary densely covered with ± long whitish appressed hairs, bilocular. Functionally male flowers with corolla tube cylindrical, 1.2–1.5 mm long, ca 0.8 mm wide at base and ca 1 mm wide at throat; corolla lobes 1.2–1.5 mm long, ca 1 mm wide at base; anthers 0.6–0.8 × 0.3–0.5 mm, exserted from the corolla tube for 4/5ths of their length at anthesis, multilocellate; style ca 1.5 mm long, stigma knob-like, reaching the same height as the anthers or somewhat topped by them at anthesis; ovary 0.5–0.6 × ca 0.3 mm, either with a single underdeveloped pendulous ovule per locule or locules empty or not formed. Functionally female flowers with corolla tube campanulate, ca 1 mm long, ca 0.9 mm wide at base and ca 1.4 mm wide at throat; corolla lobes 0.8–1 mm long, ca 0.8 mm wide at base; anthers 0.5–0.8 × ca 0.3 mm, upper half exserted from the corolla tube at anthesis, not producing viable pollen; style 1.3–1.5 mm long, stigma positioned above the level of the anthers at anthesis, knob-like when young, opening into two broad lobes, much wider than long, curved and folded, with papillae present on the adaxial surface and in a broad band on the margins of the lobes (Fig.
Occurring in the Toliara Province, in the Atsimo-Andrefana, Androy, and Anosy Regions; seemingly widespread in the southern part of Madagascar from Taolagnaro in the east, to Cap Sainte Marie in the south, and Manombo (north of Toliara) in the west. Occurring in the Tsimanampetsotse National Park and Cap Sainte Marie Special Reserve (Fig.
Dry deciduous forest, spiny forest, dry scrub sometimes as low as 0.5 m, on limestone covered by white sand; elevation 20–200 m.
Flowers in November–April and fruits in January–April.
The species is named for the multilocellate anthers in the male flowers, a feature hitherto not known in the genus Pyrostria nor in the tribe Vanguerieae.
This assessment is based on 14 herbarium specimens collected between 1955 and 2010. The EOO of Pyrostria multilocellata is estimated to be 33240 km2, exceeding the upper limit of the Vulnerable category under criterion B1. The AOO is 44 km2, which complies with the Endangered category under criterion B2. The species occurs in 11 locations, which exceeds the Vulnerable category under subcriterion ‘a’ of criterion B2. Pyrostria multilocellata occurs in two protected areas: Tsimanampetsotse National Park and Cap Sainte Marie Special Reserve but both are threatened to a certain extent by human activities, notably an overexploitation of natural resources by local populations (
MADAGASCAR – Toliara province, Atsimo-Andrefana region • près d’Ambatry, S de Betioky; 14 Jan. 1962; fl. (functionally male); Capuron 20692-SF; BR [BR0000009311268], P • La Table, 15 km from Toliara on Route Nationale 7; 4 Jan. 1999; fl. (functionally male); De Block, Leyman, Dessein, Rakotonasolo & Randriamboavonjy 544; BR [BR0000009125025], MO*, P*, S*, TAN • La Table, 15 km from Toliara on Route Nationale 7; 4 Jan. 1999; fl. (functionally female), fr.; De Block, Leyman, Dessein, Rakotonasolo & Randriamboavonjy 545; BR [BR0000009125018], MO*, TAN • Road from La Table to Sept Lacs; 2 Feb. 2007; fl. (functionally male); De Block, Groeninckx & Rakotonasolo 2307; BR [BR0000006745622], MO*, P*, TAN • Lac Tsimanampetsotsa; 5 Feb. 2007; fl. (functionally female); Groeninckx, De Block & Rakotonasolo 217; BR [BR0000005272235], MO*, P*, TAN • Route Nationale 10, km 111, entre Betioky & Ejeda; 190 m; 4 Feb. 1990; fl. (functionally male), fr. (separate branches); Labat, Du Puy & Phillipson 2066; BR [BR0000017834490], MO n.v., P online • 9 km N of Manombo along coast near Fiserenamasay; 20 m; 23 Feb. 1993; fl. (functionally female); Phillipson & Raharilala 4124; BR [BR0000009139244], MO n.v. – Toliara province, Androy region • Sur les pentes du massif de l’Angavo, E d’Antanimora; Nov. 1955; fl. (functionally male); Capuron 11731-SF; BR [BR0000009222373], P • 43 km from Ambovombe on road to Betroka; 2 Feb. 2007; fl. (functionally male); De Block, Groeninckx & Rakotonasolo 2330; BR [BR0000006745325], MO*, P*, TAN • Sakamasy forest, route de Tsihombe à Ambovombe, ca 8 km de Tsihombe; 4 Apr. 2010; fl. (functionally male); De Block, Groeninckx & Rakotonasolo 2439; BR [BR0000005444724], K*, MO*, TAN • Fort-Dauphin, Ambovombe district, commune Ambohimalaza, N of fokotany Mahatomotsy; 29 Mar. 2010; fr.; Groeninckx, De Block & Rakotonasolo 301; BR [BR0000005512096], MO*, P*, TAN • Fort-Dauphin, close to Cap Sainte Marie National Park; 3 Apr. 2010; fl. (functionally female); Groeninckx, De Block & Rakotonasolo 323; BR [BR0000005561933, BR0000020242756], MO*, TAN • Fort-Dauphin, Cap Sainte Marie National Park; 3 Apr. 2010; fl. (functionally female), fr.; Groeninckx, De Block & Rakotonasolo 325; BR [BR0000005561735], TAN. – Toliara province, Anosy region • On Route Nationale 13 from Fort-Dauphin to Ambovombe, pk 40 from Fort Dauphin; 26 Mar. 2010; fl. (functionally male); De Block, Groeninckx & Rakotonasolo 2381; BR [BR0000005518845], TAN.
In living plants, the leaves are dark green or green above and somewhat paler below. Fruits were only observed when green, even though seeds seem mature when dissecting these green fruits. Ovary, calyx tube and calyx lobes are green, the ovary with whitish appressed pubescence. The corolla is pale green, white or yellowish at anthesis. Anthers and filaments are described as white, with anthers turning brownish with age. Style and stigma are described as white or pale green.
Functionally male and female flowers differ in the shape and size of the corolla tube (cylindrical, 1.2–1.5 mm long in functionally male flowers vs campanulate, ca 1 mm long in functionally female flowers), the length of the corolla lobes (1.2–1.5 vs 0.8–1.0 mm long), and the position of the stigma (at the level of the anthers or somewhat topped by them vs stigma positioned above the anthers). Anthers of functionally male flowers are somewhat more exserted from the corolla tube than those of functionally female flowers. Furthermore, the anthers are multilocellate vs not producing viable pollen. Also, the ovary is larger (0.8–1.2 × ca 1.0 mm vs 0.5–0.6 × ca 0.3 mm) with normal-sized ovules developing in functionally female flowers (vs ovules underdeveloped or locules empty or not formed). There are no differences between male and female inflorescences; they are both uniflorous.
Multilocellate anthers have hitherto not been reported from Pyrostria nor from the tribe Vanguerieae. They are known to occur sporadically in scattered genera of Rubiaceae, such as Aidia Lour. (Gardenieae), Calycosiphonia Pierre ex Robbr. (Coffeeae), Isertia Schreb. (
BV is the editor in chief of Plant Ecology and Evolution but was not involved in the editorial process of the manuscript and had no influence on the final decision.
We thank the curators of the P herbarium for arranging a loan of unmounted material and those of MO for sending duplicates of relevant material. We are grateful to Ms Hilde Orye for the excellent illustrations. Ms Iris Van der Beeten is thanked for critical point drying and photographing the SEM samples. We thank the Missouri Botanical Garden, Madagascar Program, for logistical support and for help with arranging collecting permits; the Parc Botanique et Zoologique de Tsimbazaza for help with arranging exportation permits and the DGF (Direction Générale des Forêts) of Madagascar for issuing these permits. Financial support for fieldwork was provided by the Research Foundation - Flanders (FWO).
List of GenBank accession numbers for sequences used in the analysis and information on voucher specimens.