Research Article |
Corresponding author: Gbèwonmèdéa Hospice Dassou ( daspice2@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Brecht Verstraete
© 2024 Gbèwonmèdéa Hospice Dassou, Gafarou Agoundé, Pathmos Akouété, Gnimansou Abraham Favi, Ghyslain Chabi Kpétikou, Kolawolé Valère Salako, Jéronime Marie-Ange Sènami Ouachinou, Judicael Makponsè, Amadou Malé Kouyaté, İdris Sari, Romain Lucas Glèlè Kakaï, Hounnankpon Yédomonhan, Aristide Cossi Adomou.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Dassou GH, Agoundé G, Akouété P, Favi GA, Kpétikou GC, Salako KV, Ouachinou J, Makponsè J, Kouyaté AM, Sari I, Glèlè Kakaï RL, Yédomonhan H, Adomou AC (2024) Past, present, and future potential distributions of the African multipurpose tree Detarium senegalense (Fabaceae). Plant Ecology and Evolution 157(3): 343-357. https://doi.org/10.5091/plecevo.122470
|
Background and aims – Climate change induces increasing temperatures and drought, with possible profound shifts in species’ presence and distribution. Ecological niche models are widely used to assess plant species responses to climate change. However, such data are scarce for West Africa, particularly for vulnerable multipurpose species. This study focuses on modelling the ecological niche and the conservation status of the multipurpose tree Detarium senegalense to improve insights into its habitat suitability in West Africa under past, present, and future climatic conditions. This will provide an essential basis for setting up global management plans through efficient conservation and ecological restoration policies.
Material and methods – The potential distribution of D. senegalense under past, current, and future climate scenarios were assessed using four algorithms including generalized additive models (GAM), generalized linear models (GLM), random forest (RF), and Maximum Entropy (MaxEnt). We also assessed the shift direction of suitable habitats and the conservation status of the species based on IUCN criteria. Overall, 220 occurrences were combined with a set of five bioclimatic variables to run the models.
Key results – Models performed well with good values of AUC (0.92) and TSS (0.73). Isothermality (41.10%) and Precipitation of Wettest Month (21.50%) contributed most to the distribution of the species. The distribution of D. senegalense was relatively constant from the past to the present but could decrease in the next decades. In the future, only 17.70% and 13.98% of the areas were predicted to be suitable under respectively ssp245 and ssp585. In protected areas, the suitable areas under ssp245 were estimated at 21.01% with a decrease of 2.50% and 14.60% with a decrease of 8.61% under ssp585 by 2050. The direction of the distribution shifted to the south-east under future climate scenarios. The conservation status assessment of the species is Least Concern (LC).
Conclusion – This study improves our understanding of the past, present-day, and future distribution of the species and provides support to better manage the conservation of D. senegalense in West Africa.
centroid, climate, conservation, Detarium senegalense, ecological niche modelling
The genus Detarium Juss. (Fabaceae) consists of three species found from West Tropical Africa to Sudan and it is introduced in Trinidad and Tobago (
Unfortunately, in addition to the threat of habitat degradation and its exploitation as timber, there is a growing regional trade of its fruits and seeds (
Understanding the distribution of key taxa and their response to environmental change is fundamental to their effective management (
Species distribution modelling (SDM) is one of the commonly used tools for investigating potential geographical distributions of organisms. SDM can be defined as the prediction of species distribution across the landscape based on the relationship between species occurrence and environmental variables (
The study was carried out in West Africa including Senegal, Guinea, Sierra Leone, Liberia, Ivory Coast, Ghana, Burkina Faso, Togo, Benin, and Nigeria (Fig.
Detarium senegalense is currently present in a wide geographical range across the four ecological zones: GC, SG, SZ, andS (Fig.
Occurrence data were gathered from two sources: online repositories and previously published data. Online data included the records from the Global Biodiversity Information Facility (GBIF.org 2021) and RAINBIO (
A total of three sources of environmental layers (bioclimatic, edaphic, and topography) were used. Past, current, and future climatic data were obtained at the spatial resolution of 2.5 minutes (~5 km at the equator) from WorldClim v.2.1 (
We modelled the past, current, and future distributions of D. senegalense in West Africa. Four machine learning methods were used for this purpose, and the results were averaged for the predictive models. These methods included generalized additive models (GAM) (
We evaluated the dynamics of the suitable areas and the direction of range shifts using SDMtoolbox v.1.0b (
The conservation status of D. senegalense was evaluated based on the IUCN criteria, especially B. We determined the extent of occurrence (EOO) and the area of occupancy (AOO) with the R package ConR v.1.3.0 (
Overall, five variables were identified to influence the distribution range of D. senegalense (Fig.
Diagram showing the contribution of the main variables and the performance of the model. A. Contribution of the variables involved in the model. Each variable is represented by a code: bio3 = Isothermality, bio7 = Temperature Annual Range, bio13 = Precipitation of Wettest Month, bio14 = Precipitation of Driest Month, bio15 = Precipitation Seasonality. B. Performance of the four algorithms. Values in the y-axis represent the average of 10 repetitions related to the two metrics. AUC = Area Under the Curve and TSS = True Skill Statistic.
The extent of suitability shown for the four classes (expansion, unsuitable, stable, contraction) for the five time periods (LGM, MH, current, ssp245, ssp585) is documented in Supplementary material
The MH period exhibited a constant favourable range of 1,362,492.32 km2 or 21.50% with an unsuitable range of 3,885,769.34 km2 or 60.10% (Fig.
At present, D. senegalense occurs in a large geographical range across Senegal, Guinea, Guinea-Bissau, Sierra Leone, Liberia, Gambia, Ivory Coast, Ghana, Burkina Faso, Togo, Benin, and Nigeria, and spreading across four ecological zones: Guineo-Congolian (GC), Guinea savannah (SG), Sudanian savannah (SZ), and very lower part of the Sahelian savannah (S) zones (Fig.
Regarding the potential distribution of D. senegalense in the future, the stable ranges were 506,147.78 km2 or 17.70% under ssp245 and 157,558 km2 or 13.98% under ssp585 by horizon-time 2050 (Fig.
The centroid of the suitable area for D. senegalense revealed different patterns of range change shift direction (Fig.
All PAs located between 6°N–13°N and 12°W–10°E were currently suitable for the species (Fig.
According to the future scenario (ssp245), most of the protected areas that are suitable under current conditions should also be suitable for the species by 2050. However, some unsuitable protected areas are predicted under this scenario. These are located mainly in the south-west and north-west of Ghana and the south-east and north of Ivory Coast, in the SG and GC zones respectively. In addition, some unsuitable PAs are predicted to a slight extent in the SZ zone to the east of the GC zone in Nigeria and in the east of the SG and GC zones in Guinea. The extent of suitability related to each class within the protected areas is provided in Supplementary material
The status of D. senegalense based on IUCN criteria across West Africa was documented in Fig.
Environmental factors play an important role in forest establishment and persistence (
The distribution of Detarium senegalense throughout West Africa was mainly affected by isothermality (bio3). Overall, isothermality refers to how similar the average daily maximum and minimum temperatures are throughout the year (
The current study assessed the dynamics of D. senegalense distribution from the past to the predicted future suitable areas. In general, our findings revealed that the suitability range was relatively stable from the last glacial maximum to the present day. In addition, suitable habitats occurred from Nigeria to Sierra Leone, and from the Guinean savannah to the evergreen forest ecological zones. However, a study of a population in Togo indicated that adult individuals are rare and that there is a low regeneration rate, and thus a predominance of small-diameter trees (
Moreover, the suitable areas of the species shifted from low latitudes to high latitudes from the Last Glacial Maximum to the Mid-Holocene. These findings are consistent with those of
According to
Ecological niche modelling or species niche modelling is a powerful and widely used tool to predict the occurrence of many taxa based on environmental factors (
The study also addressed the conservation status of the species under current conditions. Our models predicted the suitable areas for the conservation of the target species were located in the GC zones of Sierra Leone, Liberia, Ivory Coast, Ghana, Togo, Benin, and Nigeria. Furthermore, most protected areas that are suitable under current conditions should be suitable for the species by 2050, except for the south-west and north-west of Ghana and the south-east and north of Ivory Coast, in the SG and Guinean climatic zones, respectively. Based on these findings, we recommend both in situ and ex situ conservation, as the species’ suitable habitats are expected to decrease both within and outside of protected areas. According to
Given the usefulness of species distribution models in conservation research (
By reducing areas with suitable climatic conditions, climate change may disrupt key ecological interactions and compromise species sustainability and the dynamics of populations of plants in their geographical ranges. This study revealed that the current suitable environmental areas for D. senegalense would contract under future climate change scenarios across West Africa. The increasing unsuitability was also predicted in protected areas, pointing to a need for setting up sustainable management plans. Isothermality and precipitation were shown to be the main factors that govern the distribution of the species and provided insight into their ecological requirements. Given the announced decline in habitat suitability of D. senegalense in the future, associated with threats due to overuse for seed trading, timber, and medicinal products, and the low regeneration potential of this species, in situ conservation may not be a one-stop solution but should be complemented with ex situ conservation. More broadly, the findings of this study could lead to consistent knowledge on the future potential distribution of West African species and appear fundamental to reducing species loss through early sustainable management strategies.
We thank the International Foundation for Science for supporting the work through Grant N° I-1-D-6362 given to Gbèwonmèdéa Hospice Dassou. The authors extend their appreciation to the editor and reviewers for their useful comments and suggestions on the manuscript.
Remaining variables after the Pearson Correlation test.
Variables contributions obtained from the jackknife test.
Average of the response curves for the four models used.
Estimations of suitable area in km2 for the whole study area and protected areas.