Research Article |
Corresponding author: Emerson R. Pansarin ( epansarin@ffclrp.usp.br ) Academic editor: André Simões
© 2024 Emerson R. Pansarin, Marcelo R. Miranda.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Pansarin ER, Miranda MR (2024) Clarifying the dubious identity of Vanilla dubia Hoehne (Orchidaceae) and its relatives. Plant Ecology and Evolution 157(2): 236-243. https://doi.org/10.5091/plecevo.121915
|
Background and aims – Brazil has more than 40 species of Vanilla. Some taxa have been considered to be obscure since they are known only from the type specimen. This is the case of some south-eastern Brazilian species such as V. dubia and V. dungsii. While studying the diversity of Brazilian Vanilla, plants of an unidentified species were found in Ubatuba, São Paulo, Brazil. After flowering, it was confirmed that the species corresponded to the obscure V. dubia.
Material and methods – A redescription of V. dubia is provided and a morphological comparison with the related taxa V. dungsii and V. paulista is presented. An illustration of V. dubia is provided, and its geographic distribution is presented. The identity of the enigmatic V. dungsii is also clarified based on holotype examination and on images of living specimens.
Key results – Vanilla dubia is recognized by its coriaceous leaves with prominent vascular bundles in transverse section, by its white 3-lobed labellum with yellow lobes and undulate-crenulate margins, and by its tuberculate appendages on the apical portion of the labellar crest. Morphological characteristics suggest a close relationship of V. dubia with V. dungsii and V. paulista. Vanilla dubia occurs in the Dense Ombrophilous Forest, while V. paulista occurs in the Semi-deciduous Mesophytic Forest, and V. dungsii is endemic to the Dense Montane Ombrophilous Forest. Based on current data, V. dubia is assessed as Endangered.
Conclusion – Evaluation of vegetative and reproductive characters from living and herbaria specimens is crucial to understanding the identity and species boundaries of Vanilla. The data presented here show that the species occurring in the Atlantic Forest, V. dubia and V. dungsii, are more closely related to each other than to V. paulista, which occurs in Semi-deciduous Mesophytic Forests. A proposal to change the status of V. dungsii as a subspecies of V. dubia can be further considered.
Atlantic Forest, Neotropics, systematics, taxonomy, Vanilleae, Vanilloideae
Vanilla Mill. encompasses more than 100 species distributed throughout tropical and subtropical regions of the Americas, Asia, and Africa (
In the course of studies on Neotropical Vanilla, we found populations of a Vanilla species whose characteristics strongly agree with those of V. dubia. Based on the examination of the protologues of the Brazilian species, in addition to a study of herbarium specimens, the plants were found to correspond to the obscure V. dubia. A redescription of this rare taxon is presented, and a morphological comparison with morphologically related taxa (V. dungsii and V. paulista) is provided. A detailed illustration of V. dubia based on living specimens is presented, and the geographic distribution of this rare taxon is provided based on our recent findings. The identity of the enigmatic V. dungsii is also clarified based on holotype examination and on images of living specimens.
Fresh and herbarium material of flowering and fruiting plants from V. dubia and its relatives was used for the study. The living material was collected from Brazilian populations and maintained in the Vanilla germplasm bank of the LBMBP Orchid House (Orchidarium of the Laboratory of Molecular Biology and Systematics of Plants), University of São Paulo (FFCLRP-USP), Brazil, available at https://www.lbmbplab.net/vanillacollection. Flowering and fruiting specimens were vouchered according to usual techniques (
Plant structures were measured using a vernier calliper. The vegetative structures, inflorescences, and flowers were photographed with a Nikon D-SLR D800 camera and a Micro Nikkor 105 mm f2.8 lens. Floral details were analyzed with a Stereozoom Leica S8 APO stereomicroscope with an integrated photo output. Digitized images were used for diagramming a template over a black background according to the model presented by
Comparative leaf anatomy between V. dubia and V. paulista was carried out using fresh material. Adult leaves from the third apical node were collected from individuals maintained under cultivation at the LBMBP Orchid House. Plants were collected in the field and kept under the same cultivation conditions for at least three years. The median portion of the leaves were manually sectioned and examined with a light microscope. Images of transversal cuts were captured with a Leica DM500 light microscope using a Leica ICC50 video camera attached to a PC and IM50 image analysis software.
The distribution map of V. dubia and morphologically related species was based on both herbarium material and living specimens from the Vanilla germplasm bank (LBMBP Orchid House). The map with the geographic distribution of V. dubia was produced with QGIS v.3.32 (
BRAZIL • s.loc.; s.d.; Schwacke 11107; holotype: RB [RB00542722, accession n° 37014].
Nomadic vines, long scandent. Roots axillary, 1.6–2.1 mm diam., whitish to greenish brown, one per node. Stem climbing, sinuous, cylindrical, fleshy, slightly sulcate, glabrous dark green; internodes 55–130 × 3–6 mm. Leaves 5.5–22 × 2–4.8 cm, alternate, distichous, lanceolate to oblanceolate, rarely elliptic, asymmetric, coriaceous, glabrous, dark green, with prominent and parallelly arranged vascular bundles in transverse section, margin entire, apex acuminate, pseudopetiolate; pseudopetiole sulcate, up to 1.8 cm long. Inflorescence 3.7–7 cm long, axillary, racemose, with up to 20 flowers opening in succession; 1 flower opening each morning; bracts 3–5.2 mm long progressively smaller toward the apex, alternate, triangular to ovate, coriaceous, concave, patent, apex acute. Flowers resupinate, pedicellate, with an abscission layer between perianth and ovary; pedicel with ovary 3.5–3.9 × 0.3–0.35 cm, straight to incurved, dilated at the apex, subcylindrical in transverse section, white along the pedicel and green along the ovary. Sepals 6–6.2 × 1.1–1.3 cm, free, oblanceolate, fleshy, slightly concave, internally cream-coloured, externally greenish, apex obtuse, margin entire, reflexed at apex; dorsal sepal symmetric; lateral sepals asymmetric. Petals 5.8–6.1 × 0.8–1.2 cm, free, lanceolate to slightly spatulate, asymmetric, membranous, apex acute, slightly reflexed, internally cream-coloured, externally greenish, adaxial surface with a central and longitudinally arranged keel. Labellum 3-lobed, 5.8–6.2 × 3–3.2 cm, unguiculate, tubular, fused to the column along the margins from the base, up to 3.6 cm long, white, yellowish in the distal portion, inner surface with longitudinal brownish stripes, with a central crest near the apex, and with a penicillate callus just below the anther; central crest ca 5 mm wide, with large yellow and tuberculate protrusions near the apex, on the midlobe; penicillate callus 4–4.5 × 3.5–3.8 mm, white; labellum margins fused from the base to ca 3/4 of the column length forming a tubular nectar chamber; nectar chamber 2.2–2.4 cm long; lateral lobes obliquely rounded, overlapping above the column, margins undulate to crenulate; apical lobe emarginated, reflexed, margin undulate to slightly crenulate. Column 4.5–4.7 × 0.3–0.35 cm, semi-cylindrical, slender, base attenuate, dilated to the apex, with white-hyaline hairs close to the stigma, apex with two lateral wings; anther 4.7–5 × 3.7–4.2 mm, rhomboid, white, versatile; rostellum 4.5–4.7 × 3.4–3.6 mm, trapezoidal, membranous, white. Fruits 5–7 × 1.2–1.5 cm, linear, incurved, subcylindrical in transverse section, fleshy, indehiscent, green when immature, black when mature. Seeds ovate, black.
Vanilla dubia Hoehne. A. Inflorescence. B. Leaf. Note the asymmetrical shape of the leaf blade and the acuminate apex. C. Flower in front view. D. Flower in lateral view. E. Flower in diagonal view. F. Dissected perianth. G. Detail of the adaxial surface of a petal showing the longitudinal keel. H. Detail of the apex of the labellum of a flower showing the brown longitudinal lines and the central crest with yellow projections. I. Detail of the labellum showing the penicillate callus and the central labellar crest. J. Labellum in dorsal view. K. Labellum in lateral view. L. Longitudinal section of the labellum. Note the penicillate callus (arrow), the anther (a), and the rostellum (arrowhead). M. Column in lateral view. N. Apex of the column: in abaxial view with an articulated and disarticulated anther (above), in lateral view with an articulated anther (mid), in lateral view with a disarticulated anther (bellow). O. Anther in dorsal view (left) and ventral view (right). P. Immature fruit. Based on E.R. Pansarin & M.R. Miranda 1574 (LBMBP). Photographs by Emerson Pansarin.
Comparison of the morphological features of Vanilla dubia and related species. Vanilla paulista data were obtained from
Characters | V. dubia | V. dungsii | V. paulista |
Habitat | Dense Ombrophilous Forest | Dense Montane Ombrophilous Forest | Semi-deciduous Mesophytic Forest |
Internode length (cm) | 5.5–13 | 16–18 | 4.2–10 |
Leaf texture | coriaceous | coriaceous | fleshy |
Leaf size (cm) | 5.5–22 × 2–4.8 | 20–21 × 4–5 | 9.2–16.2 × 2.5–3.2 |
Inflorescence length (cm) | 2.7–7 | ca 5 | 4–5.2 |
Bract length (mm) | 3–5.2 | 1.3–2.6 | 3.5–5 |
Sepals (cm) | 6–6.2 × 1.1–1.3 | 5–6.5 × 0.8–1 | 5.7–7.8 × 0.7–1.4 |
Petals (cm) | 5.8–6.1 × 0.8–1.2 | 5.5 × 1–1.1 | 6.5–7.1 × 0.8–1.3 |
Labellum (cm) | 5.8–6.2 × 3–3.2 | 5 × 2.5 | 5.7–6.9 × 3.3–3.5 |
Longitudinal labellar bands | brown | brown | yellow |
Arrangement of labellar protrusions | 3–5 rows | 3–5 rows | 1–3 rows |
Shape of labellar protrusions | tuberculate | tuberculate | papillous |
Colour of labellar protrusions | yellow | brownish | white |
Column length (cm) | 4.5–4.7 | ca 3.5 | 4.4–4.8 |
Vanilla dubia occurs in primary forests of the Atlantic Rainforest in south-eastern Brazil (Fig.
Map with records of occurrence of Vanilla dubia Hoehne and related species, Vanilla dungsii Pabst and Vanilla paulista Fraga & Pansarin. Records of occurrence of V. paulista and V. dungsii are based on the locality of type specimens. Map created with QGIS v.32.2 (
Vanilla dubia blooms from October to December. The fruits ripen between May and June.
Endangered: EN B2ab(i,ii,iii). Vanilla dubia is an uncommon and rarely collected species currently known to grow in the Atlantic Forest areas of south-eastern Brazil. The populations found are composed of few sparse specimens. The extent of occurrence (EOO) is estimated to be 7,953.845 km2, which falls within the limits for Vulnerable (VU) under subcriterion B1, according to the IUCN red list categories and criteria and guidelines. The area of occupancy (AOO) is estimated to be 24 km2 (cell width 2 km), which falls within the limits for Endangered (EN) under criterion B2 (area of occupancy). Considering that the Atlantic Forest areas have been reduced to scattered fragments due to extensive human occupation, we project a continuing decline in (i) extent of occurrence, (ii) area of occupancy, and (iii) extent and/or quality of habitat of V. dubia. Based on these threats and on the fact that the species is distributed in less than five locations, V. dubia is assessed as Endangered (EN B2ab(i,ii,iii)).
BRAZIL – Espírito Santo • Santa Leopoldina, Rio das Farinhas; 20°6’7”S, 40°36’58”W; 40 m; 16 Oct. 2003; A.P. Fontana 626; MBML • Moxafongo; 20°6’53”S, 40°31’54”W; 150 m; 19 Nov. 2005; A.P. Fontana, C. Esgario, A.M. de Assis, K.F.O. Faria & V. Pagund 1797; MBML • Santa Teresa, Topo do Canaã; 19°55’5”S, 40°35’58”W; 685 m; 4 Apr. 2004; R.R. Vervloet et al. 1841; MBML • Alto Santo Antônio; 19°53’14”S, 40°34’32”W; 25 Feb. 2005; A.P. Fontana; et al. 1131; MBML • Estrada da Pedra da Onça; 19°53’29”S, 40°49’8”W; 10 Sep. 1998; L. Kollmann, E. Bausen & W. Pizziolo 519; MBML. – São Paulo • Ubatuba, Praia Dura; 23°29’35”S, 45°10’30”W; 30 m; E.R. Pansarin & M.R. Miranda 1574; LBMBP.
Vanilla dubia is easily recognized by its coriaceous and dark-green leaves with prominent and parallelly-arranged vascular bundles in transverse section (Fig.
A. Variation in the shape of leaf blades of Vanilla dubia Hoehne, based on E.R. Pansarin & M.R. Miranda 1574 (LBMBP). B. Leaf of V. paulista Fraga & Pansarin, based on E.R. Pansarin 727 (UEC). C. Comparative anatomy of the mid portion of leaf blades of V. dubia (above) and V. paulista (below). Photographs by Emerson Pansarin.
Comparative morphology of the flowers of Vanilla dubia Hoehne and related species. A. Vanilla dubia Hoehne (Ubatuba, São Paulo). B. Vanilla dungsii Pabst (Nova Friburgo, Rio de Janeiro). C. Vanilla paulista Fraga & Pansarin (Jundiaí, São Paulo). Details bellow the flowers (oval frames) show the types of labellar protrusions among the three Vanilla species. A. Based on E.R. Pansarin & M.R. Miranda 1574 (LBMBP). B. Based on a living specimen collected in Nova Friburgo, Rio de Janeiro. C. Based on E.R. Pansarin 727 (UEC). Photographs by Emerson Pansarin (A and C), and Jorge Gastin (B).
Several studies have pointed out the need to clarify the circumscription of obscure species of Vanilla (e.g.
A close relationship between Vanilla dubia and V. paulista has been proposed (
Although V. dubia is supposed to occur in Minas Gerais (
Comparison of vegetative and reproductive characteristics between living specimens and those deposited in herbaria was crucial to understanding the identity and species boundaries of V. dubia and its relatives. The data presented here show that the species occurring in the Atlantic Forest, V. dubia and V. dungsii, are more closely related to each other than to V. paulista, which occurs in semi-deciduous mesophytic forests. A proposal to change the status of V. dungsii as a subspecies of V. dubia can be further considered after detailed studies on the reproductive isolation of their populations.
The author thanks ICMBIO for permission to collect (Protocol SISBIO number 35178-1), and Elettra Greene for the English revision. Research supported by the São Paulo Research Foundation – FAPESP (Grant 2018/07357-5) and by CNPq (Productivity Research Grant 301773/2019-0).